| Platinum | Il Chianti Italian Steak and Seafood |
| Gold | Pasta Shop Ristorante & Art Gallery |
| Silver | Azzurra Cucina Italiano |
| Bronze | Ventano Italian Grill & Seafood |
| Top Pick | Bottiglia Cucina & Enoteca |
| Top Pick | Fratelli's Pizza Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Metro Pizza |
| Top Pick | Sammy's Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | Those Guys Pies |
| Top Pick | Water Street Pizzeria |